SPI’RITUALISM. Under the head of animal MAGNETISM, an account is given, from the scientific point of view, of some of those mysterious phenomena which, under the name of modern spiritualism, have recently attracted so much public attention. It is proposed here to give a more complete account of these phenomena as they appear to those who hold that they are inexplicable by the commonly received laws of physics.
That these phenomena in their higher phases—as those of trance, healing by touch, and subjection to the thought and will of another mind—are intimately allied with those of mesmerism, Is obvious to all who have given any careful attention to them. Spiritualists, indeed, affirm that they differ only in this—that in the one case the operator is a mortal, in the other a disembodied human spirit possessing a spiritual body instead of a physical one. Those persons most readily susceptible to mesmeric influence generally prove to be the best mediums for spirit manifestation. Wherever mesmerism has been extensively practised, it would seem that the ground has thereby been prepared for the operators in the unseen world; and indeed, human magnetism is not unfrequently resorted to for this express purpose.
Many of the earliest and foremost advocates of spiritualism in England have traveled to spiritualism via mesmerism. As is fully shown in the correspondence of M. Billault and M. Deleuze, published in two volumes in 1836, the rnagnetists of France anticipated by at least half a century the revelations of what is now known as ‘ modern spiritualism,’ which was as humble in its origin as other great movements recorded in history which have so largely influenced mankind.
In the village of Hydesville, New York State, lived Mr. John D. Fox and family, much respected by their neighbors as honest upright people. The two youngest children, Margaret, then twelve years old, and Kate, nine, were staying with their parents. Soon after they had taken up their residence here, in December 1847, they began to hear knockings in the house, which towards the end of March increased in loudness and frequency. Mr. Fox and his wife got up night after night, lit a candle, and thoroughly searched every nook and corner of the house, but discovered nothing. When the raps came on a door, Mr. Fox would stand ready to open it the moment they were repeated, but though he opened the door on the instant, he could detect nothing, and no one was to be seen; nor could he obtain the slightest clue to the cause of these disturbances. But through all these annoyances Mr. and Mrs. Fox clung to the belief that some natural explanation of them would be found. Nor did they abandon this hope till the last night of March 1848.
Wearied out by a succession of sleepless nights, and of fruitless attempts to penetrate the mystery, the family had retired very early to rest; but scarcely had the mother seen the children safely in bed, and was retiring to rest herself, when the children cried out: ‘ Here they are again! ‘ The mother chid them, and lay down. Thereupon the noises became louder and more startling. Mrs. Fox called in her husband. The night being windy, it suggested to him that it might be the rattling of the sashes. He tried several, shaking them to hear if they were loose. Kate happened to remark that as often as her father shook a window-sash, the noises seemed to reply. Turning to where the noise was, she snapped her fingers, and called out ‘ Here, do as I do?’ The knockings instantly responded. She tried, by silently bringing together her thumb and forefinger, whether she could still obtain a response. Yes! It—the mysterious something—could see, then, as well as hear! She called her mother: ‘Only look, mother,’ she said, bringing her finger and thumb together as before. And as often as she repeated the noiseless motion, just so often responded the raps. This at once arrested the mother’s attention. ‘Count ten,’ she said; ten strokes were distinctly given. ‘ How old is my daughter Margaret?’ Twelve strokes responded. ‘And Kate?’ Nine! ‘What can all this mean?’ was Mrs. Fox’s thought. Who was answering her? Was it only some mysterious echo of her own thought? The answers to the next question she put seemed to refute this idea. ‘ How many children have I?’ she asked aloud. Seven strokes. ‘Ah!’ she thought, ‘it can blunder sometimes.’ And then, aloud, ‘Try again.’ Still seven strokes as before Of a sudden a thought crossed her mind : ‘ Are they all alive?’ she asked. Silence for answer. ‘How many are living?’ Six strokes. ‘How many dead?’ A single stroke; she had lost a child. Then she asked, ‘ Are you a man?’ No answer. ‘ Are you a spirit?’ It rapped. ‘ May my neighbors hear if I call them?’ It rapped again. Thereupon she asked her husband to call a neighbor, a Mrs. Redfield, who came in laughing. But her mirth was soon changed. The answers to her inquiries were as prompt and pertinent as they had been to those of Mrs. Fox. She was struck with awe; and when, in reply to a question about the number of her children, by rapping four, instead of three, as she expected, it reminded her of a little daughter, Mary, whom she had recently lost, the mother burst into tears.
Of course a knowledge of these things could not be kept secret. The news soon spread, and the utmost excitement prevailed in the little village and beyond it. Neighbors flocked in and the house was besieged and the time of the family wholly taken up with curious and eager visitors. Formal depositions appeared in more than one publication. The earliest of these, published April 1848 —a pamphlet of forty pages—contains twenty-one certificates, chiefly given by the immediate neighbors. Most of the witnesses offer to confirm their statements, if necessary, under oath, and express their conviction that the family had no agency in producing the sounds.
It was found that these were more marked in the presence of Kate Fox, and in the hope of getting rid of these annoyances, Kate was sent on a visit to Mrs. Fish, a married sister, at Rochester. The only result being that, while the rappings did not cease at Hydesville, a new and more extended scene of operations was given them at Rochester, whither they followed Kate, and were found also to accompany her sister; and a girl who resided with them.
On one occasion, a visitor suggested that the alphabet should be called over, to see if the sounds would respond to the required letters, and so spell out a communication. A shower of raps followed, as if to say: ‘Yes, that is what we want!’ The first message so given, was : ‘ We are all your dear friends and relatives.’ Then the name of ‘ Jacob Smith,’ Mrs. Fish’s grandfather, was given. Previous to the spiritual telegraphy thus commenced, the only mode of communication had been by asking-questions, one rap being understood as an answer in the negative, three in the affirmative, and two, doubtful, or that the answer could not then be given. It was now asked that a signal should be given when the alphabet was required; this was responded to by five strokes, which was henceforth understood as a call for the alphabet; and so a code of signals was instituted.
Similar demonstrations occurred about this time, independently, in the homes of some of the most respectable inhabitants of Rochester. At length it was communicated by the rapping that the facts should be given to the world, with a view to open up a more extended intercourse: and instructions were given as to where, how, and by whom, this was to be done. There was much difficulty in getting the parties named to take the responsibility, and incur the discredit and ridicule of this step : but their scruples were at length overcome; and on the 14th of November 1848, a public lecture, giving a simple narrative of the facts, was delivered in the Corinthian Hall, Rochester, to an audience of about four hundred people. The rappings, as had been promised, were distinctly heard in all parts of the hall; and a committee was appointed by the audience to investigate the subject, and report at a subsequent meeting. The committee all agreed that the sounds were heard; but they entirely failed to discover any means by which they were produced.
This result was very different to what had been confidently anticipated, and the dissatisfied audience, amazed at the failure, appointed a second committee, which it was expected would make such an investigation as could not fail to find out the trick; and when this committee, after the strictest investigation, only continued the judgment of its predecessor, the excitement became intense; and a third committee was appointed, consisting of those who had shown the most determined hostility to the reports of the previous committees, and who had expressed the utmost confidence in their ability to detect the imposition. It certainly was no fault of theirs that they did not- They resorted to every means their ingenuity could devise; but no fraud could be detected, no explanation given. The ‘mediums’ were separated, and their friends were rigorously excluded from the sittings of the committee. They were unexpectedly removed, first to one house, then to another. A committee of ladies divested them of their clothing; feather pillows were placed under their feet; the stethoscope was applied to see that there was no movement of the lungs by which the sounds could be made. Under every condition imposed, the obstinate raps came—on doors, floors, walls, ceiling; the place seemed alive with them. When this final committee, baffled and mortified, made known their failure, the meeting broke up in the greatest excitement and confusion. But the object was gained : the facts were reported and commented on in all the journals throughout the country.
Circles for investigation were now everywhere formed, and not only were the rappings obtained, but new phases of these strange phenomena were constantly developed. In Forty Years of American Life, by Thomas Low Nichols, M.D., we read : ‘ Dials were made with movable hands, which pointed out letters and answered questions without apparent human aid. The hands of mediums, acting convulsively, and, as they averred, without their volition, wrote things apparently beyond their knowledge, in documents purporting to be signed by departed spirits. Their writings were sometimes made upside down, or reversed so as only to be read through the paper or in a mirror. Some mediums wrote with both hands at a time, different messages, without, as they said, being conscious of either. There were speaking mediums, who declared themselves to be the merely passive instruments of the spirits. Some represented, most faithfully, it was said, the actions, voices, and appearance of persons long dead; others, blindfolded, drew portraits, said to be likenesses of deceased persons they had never seen—the ordinary work of hours being done in a few minutes. Sometimes the names of deceased persons, and short messages, appeared in raised red lines upon the skin of the medium. Ponderous bodies, as heavy dining-tables and pianofortes, were raised from the floor, falling again with a crash and jar. Tables on which several persons were seated were in like manner raised into the air by some invisible force. Mediums are said to have been raised into the air, and floated about above the heads of the spectators. Writings and pictures were produced without visible hands. Persons were touched by invisible, and sometimes by visible hands. Various musical instruments were played upon without visible agency. Strange feats of legerdemain, as the untying of complicated rope knottings in an incredibly short time, astonished many. Voices were heard, which purported to he those of spirits. In a word, over a vast extent of country, from east to west, these phenomena existed, or were said to exist, in hundreds of places, and were witnessed by many thousands of people—numbers of whom were of the highest credibility, and the mass of those persons whose testimony no one would think of impeaching in a trial of life and death.’
Many theories were invented to explain these phenomena: they are now for the most part obsolete or forgotten. Each theory generally began by exploding its predecessors, and was in turn exploded by its successors. No sooner was a theory invented to explain one class of facts, than another sprang up for which it made no provision, and to which it was manifestly inadequate. Not only did the flame spread, but sometimes the extinguishers caught fire; and those who at first were its opponents, ended as its advocates. The most obdurate materialists became convinced of a future life for man by the experimental evidence spiritualism supplied. For instance, Professor Hare instituted a series of experiments intended to prove that the phenomena were wholly due to natural causes : and the public, and men of science in particular, were surprised when, in place of this explanation, there appeared a large work with his name as its author, entitled Spiritualism Scientifically Demonstrated; and with diagrams of ingenious apparatus invented by him to test the genuineness of the phenomena. The Hon. J. W. Edmonds, judge in the Supreme Court of Appeal for the state of New York, brought to bear upon the subject a mind trained by long judicial experience, and the careful sifting of evidence. He investigated with many different mediums, and took notes as carefully as though in court. To his great astonishment he found he was himself a medium, and under the title Spiritualism, he published two large volumes, narrating his investigations, visions, and spiritual communications. His daughter. Laura, also became a medium, and under some foreign influence would sometimes answer freely in languages with which in her normal state she was wholly unacquainted.
Reports of these marvels soon crossed the Atlantic; but in England, for a long time, they excited little serious attention, and were generally received, not only with incredulity, but with ridicule and contempt. The visit to London of Mrs. Haydon, an American medium, in 1854, first excited any considerable degree of public interest in spiritualism. Many visited her, most of whom were puzzled, some ridiculed, a few were convinced. Among the latter were Robert Owen, the founder of English Socialism, and Dr. Ashburner, the translator of Reichenbach, and the colleague of Dr. Elliotson in the establishment of the Zoist and of the Mesmeric Infirmary. In 1855, a more remarkable medium came to England, Mr. Daniel Dunglas Home. The manifestations which occurred in his presence were soon the subject of newspaper controversy. From that time to this they have been seen and tested repeatedly by scientific and other witnesses of the highest credit and social position; and they made him a frequent and welcome guest at the Tuileries and at the courts of Berlin and St. Petersburg. A full account of his ’strange experiences is given in his> autobiography, entitled Incidents in My Life. They include nearly the whole range of ‘ manifestations ‘ referred to in the important Report of which we are about to speak.
In January 1869, the London Dialectical Society appointed a committee ‘ to investigate the phenomena alleged to be spiritual manifestations, and to report thereon.’ The committee invited evidence from all sides, and especially solicited the co-operation of scientific men. and resolved itself into sub-committees for experimental investigation and test. In July 1871, the committee presented its report, with minutes of evidence, reports of seances, and other documents, making a volume of 412 large octavo pages. The committee state that ‘ a large majority of the members of your committee have become actual witnesses to several phases of the phenomena, without the aid or presence of any professional medium, although the greater part of them commenced their investigations in an avowedly sceptical spirit.’
A synopsis of the evidence is also given as follows : ‘ Thirteen-witnesses state that they have seen heavy bodies—in some instances, men—rise slowly in the air, and remain there for some time without visible or tangible support. Fourteen witnesses testify to having seen hands or figures, not appertaining to any human being, but lifelike in appearance and mobility, which they have sometimes touched or even grasped, and which they are therefore-convinced were not the result of imposture or illusion. Five witnesses state that they have been touched by some invisible agency on various parts of the body, and often where requested, “when the hands of all present was visible. Thirteen witnesses declare that they have heard musical pieces well played upon instruments not manipulated by any ascertainable agency. Five witnesses state that they have seen red-hot coals applied to the hands or heads of several persons without producing pain or scorching; and three witnesses state that they have had the same test applied to themselves with the like immunity. Eight witnesses state that they have received detailed information through rappings, writings, or in other ways, the accuracy of which was unknown at the time to themselves or to any persons present, and which, on subsequent inquiry, was found to be correct. One witness declares that he has received a precise and detailed statement, which, nevertheless, proved to be entirely erroneous. Three witnesses state that they have been present when drawings, both in pencil and colors, were produced in so short a time, and under such conditions, as to render human agency impossible. Six witnesses declare that they have received information of future events, and that in some cases the hour and minute have been accurately foretold days and even weeks before. In addition to the above, evidence has been given of trance-speaking, of healing, of automatic writing, of the introduction of flowers and fruits into closed rooms, of voices in the air, of visions in crystals and glasses, and of the elongation of the human body.’
One of the latest scientific investigators of spiritualism is Mr. William Crookes, F.R.S., discoverer of the metal thallium, editor of the Chemical News and of the Quarterly Journal of Science. In the latter journal for January 1874 is an article by him, entitled, ‘ Notes of an Inquiry into the Phenomena called Spiritual, 1870— 1873.’ He attests phenomena similar to those affirmed by the Dialectical Society’s committee and its witnesses, which came under his notice in his own house, in the light, and with only private friends present except the medium, at times appointed by himself, and under circumstances which, he says, absolutely precluded the employment of the very simplest instrumental aids. One of the most recent phases of spiritualism in this country is ‘ spirit photographs.’ On clean and previously unused plates, marked by the sitter, and even when the sitter has used his own plates and camera, there has appeared with the sitter a second figure, which in many instances have been recognized as portraits of deceased relatives and friends. In the Spiritual Magazine for December 1872, is a list of the names and addresses of forty sitters who have so recognized these figures. They have been obtained by many photographers, both professional and amateur, in England, the United States, and on the continent of Europe.
The Spiritual Magazine (the oldest journal of spiritualism in England, and which contains a record of the movement from its establishment in January 1860) has the following as its motto : ‘ Spiritualism is based on the cardinal fact of spirit communion and influx; it is the effort to discover all truth relating to man’s spiritual nature, capacities, relations, duties, welfare, and destiny; and its application to a regenerate life. It recognizes a continuous divine inspiration in man; it aims through a careful, reverent study of facts, at a knowledge of the laws and principles which govern the occult forces of the universe; of the relations of spirit to matter, and of man to God and the spiritual world. It is thus catholic and progressive, leading to true religion as at one with the highest philosophy.’
At a conference in Liverpool in November 1873, at which delegates from about forty societies attended, steps were taken which have led to the establishment of the ‘ British National Association of Spiritualists ‘—’ to unite spiritualists of every variety of opinion for their mutual aid and benefit; to promote the study of pneumatology and psychology; to aid students and inquirers in their researches, by placing at their disposal the means of systematic investigation into the now recognized facts and phenomena, called spiritual or psychic; to make known the positive results arrived at by careful scientific research; and to direct attention to the beneficial influence which those results are calculated to exercise upon social relationships and individual conduct.’
In 1881 the chief English journals of spiritualism were Light, Medium and Daybreak, Spiritualist, and Spiritual Notes, weekly or monthly. In the United States the earliest was the Banner of Light, founded in 1857. In 1881 it was stated that there were in Germany 1 spiritualist magazine, in Austria 1, Holland 1, France 1, Belgium 4, England 7, Italy 1, Spain 5, United States 5, Argentine Republic 2, Mexico 2, Colombia 2. The literature of the movement is very voluminous. The following are important works on spiritualism : Transcendental Physics, translated from the German of Prof. Zöllner (1880), Psychic Facts, by Harrison (1880); Researches in the Phenomena, by Crookes (1874); Modern American Spiritualism, by Hardinge (1870); From Matter to Spirit, by Mrs. De Morgan, with preface by Professor De Morgan; The Two Worlds, by Thomas Brevior; Footfalls on the Boundary of Another World, and The Debatable Land, by Robert Dale Owen; History of the Supernatural, by William Howitt; A Defence of Spiritualism, by Alfred Russell Wallace; Lights and Shadows of Spiritualism, by D. D. Home (1877); Mesmerism, Spiritualism, &c., Historically and Scientifically Considered, by W. B. Carpenter, F.R.S. (1877).